The name
A name spelled by ear
Inez Fowler Johnson opens her book with a warning about the name. It “is written in many different ways,” she says, and “only one thing seems important and that is the sound of the name.” (p. 9)
The records bear her out. In the 1740s one church register at Athens, New York, writes the same father Esselstein, Esseltine and Esseltein. The family is Esseltyne at Claverack, Asseltine in Canada and Aseltine in Vermont. Of a branch in Franklin County, New York, the book says they “have always spelled their name Eseltine.” One Michigan county history prints Aseltyne and another prints Aselton. In Iowa, about 1881, one line became Azeltine and has kept it. (pp. 14, 25, 32, 36, 40)
She adds one caution of her own: this “Holland family must not be confused with the Haseltine family, who are English.” (p. 9)
Before 1700 · legend and record
The Van Ysselstynes
The book’s first chapter is borrowed from another family’s genealogy, and it begins with a legend. A “curious manuscript” in old German gives the Van Ysselsteyns a founder, Veltin, who about 500 A.D. built a castle on a rocky island in the marshes of Utrecht and bore a white sea gull as his arms. The story comes with its own warning attached: “if we may credit” it. (p. 11)
The first Van Ysselsteyns in American records stand on firmer ground. Marten Cornelise, born in the town of Ysselsteyn, was one of the fourteen founders of Schenectady in 1661. He later moved to Claverack, on the Hudson, where his homestead stayed in the family for seven or eight generations. (p. 12)
Jan Willemszen, “commonly called Jan of Leyden,” signed the application for town privileges at Bushwick in 1661. Three years later, for abusive language and an insolent letter to the magistrates, he was sentenced to stand at a stake wearing a paper that read “Lampoon writer, false accuser and defamer of its magistrates,” and was banished. He too ended at Claverack. (pp. 13–14)
Some who worked on the family, Laura Esseltine among them, believed that Conrad’s father came of Jan’s line. The book prints the material “because the searchers may prove this at a later date” and says plainly that “the line is not yet complete.” (pp. 13, 51)
Claverack, New York · 1741–1760
Isaac and Elisabeth
The proved line starts with Isaac Esselstein and his wife, Elisabeth Kelder, who lived near Claverack, close to the Hudson. The book cannot say who Isaac’s parents were. Elisabeth “was probably the daughter of Coonrad Kelder who lived in the same town.” (pp. 14–15)
The registers of several churches give them nine children: Peter in 1741, Conrad in 1743, Altje in 1745, Johannes in 1748, Marytje in 1750, Abraham in 1752, Jannitje in 1755, Agnitge in 1760, and Andrew, whose birth is not recorded. (p. 14; addenda, pp. 2–3)
A grandson’s letter remembered the family more simply, as “five sons and one daughter.” The daughter was Olive, the English form of Altje. (pp. 14, 49)
The Revolution · 1777–1786
Brothers on both sides
The Revolution divided the brothers. Conrad, Abraham and Andrew enlisted in the 8th Regiment, Albany County. Peter and John stayed loyal to the Crown and served with the British forces from 1777 to 1786. The tradition among the Canadian family, in the addenda’s words, is that “he refused to fight against the British.” (p. 15; addenda, pp. 3, 6)
As Loyalists the two were granted land in Ernstown township in Canada, 300 acres to Peter and 350 to John, and their children born before 1789 received 200 acres each. Peter died on May 15, 1826, aged 84, and is buried in the old Lutheran cemetery near Bath, Ontario. John died in the spring of 1822. (addenda, pp. 2, 5) On the map
The book’s original text had this wrong. It had Peter and John settling near Swanton and Highgate and finding themselves in Lower Canada when the boundary was drawn. The addenda corrected it, and added that the two halves of the family “apparently lived close enough so that frequent visits were made among relatives.” (p. 15; addenda, p. 3)
Swanton, Vermont · 1788–1810
Over the ice to Swanton
Conrad came north after the war. The History of Swanton, which the book quotes, calls him “one of the first settlers west of the Falls.” He arrived from Claverack in 1788 with three of his sons and went home the same year, leaving one son behind. In 1789 he moved the whole family, “coming all the way from Whitehall on the ice to Maquam Bay.” (p. 15) On the map
He raised apple trees from seed he had brought with him and set out an orchard that bore for many years. There were no mills yet at the Falls, so he took his grain to Sax’s mills in Highgate by canoe. In 1790 he was a selectman of Swanton. (p. 15)
“It was like walking on a nearly waterproof carpet which floated on a pond.”
Conrad is last mentioned in the town’s Grand List of 1810. The book does not know where or when he or his wife, Maria, died. (p. 15)
Conrad’s children · 1767–1844
Five sons
The town history gives Conrad eight children: Isaac, John, Henry, Peter, Andrew, Jane, Lydia and Margaret. The book follows the five sons. (p. 15)
Isaac, the eldest, left Vermont for Canada, near Montreal, sometime between 1800 and 1810. His sons John and Henry came from there to Michigan in 1835, six weeks on the way, “Henry with a horse and ox and John with two oxen,” and stopped at Ann Arbor to help build the first building of the University of Michigan. Isaac himself is placed in Michigan about 1837. (p. 17) On the map
John, the second son, cleared land on Maquam Bay and was one of Swanton’s first constables in 1790. His son Enos wrote the letter of January 17, 1900, on which much of the book’s account of the first generations rests. (pp. 28–29, 49–50)
Henry, a farmer, was killed by a falling tree while clearing land to build a house. His son Josiah went to Monroe County, Michigan, in 1833 and helped build the first sawmill in Toledo, Ohio. (pp. 32–33)
Peter had the farm on Maquam Bay, a property that, the book says, “has never been in the name of anyone but an Aseltine.” (pp. 15, 31)
Andrew lived on Hog Island, now West Swanton. His descendants tell that he and his wife, Candace, watched the Battle of Plattsburg from the shore of Lake Champlain in 1814, and that the son born soon afterward, Ezra Bedley, was named for the substitute who was killed there in Andrew’s place. (pp. 36, 39)
New York, Michigan, Iowa, Dakota · 1833–1881
West with the country
From Swanton the family followed the frontier. Conrad’s grandchildren were in Michigan from 1833 and in Franklin County, New York, from 1835. By the 1850s the family had reached Iowa, and later Kansas and Dakota. (pp. 17, 32, 39) All the moves, on the map
The line the compiler knew best was her own. Ezra Bedley Aseltine moved to Franklin County, New York, in 1835, to northeastern Iowa about 1855 and to Grundy County in 1864. His son Andrew Jackson, a farmer and carpenter, took the family to Wright County about 1881, and there the spelling became Azeltine. Andrew Jackson’s daughter Nina Florence married Florence Henry Fowler at Clarion, Iowa, in October 1886. Their daughter Inez compiled the book. (pp. 39–42)
The Michigan pages have details of their own. A schoolgirl’s history of the Wilson District, reprinted in the book, calls Luke Aseltine “the champion hunter,” who “kept the settlers well supplied with game, honey, and wild turkeys.” Of Lucy Aseltine, who died of diphtheria at eleven, the book records that “she had pieced 11 quilts in these short years.” (pp. 22–25)
Allied families
The families they married
The book also sets out the families the Aseltines married into, some in a few lines and some at length.
Three of the four daughters of Claudius Cheney of St. Albans, Vermont, married Aseltines. The fourth married Amherst Thayer of Swanton. (pp. 50, 53) The Cheney family
The Sweets were the “Bonesetter Sweets” of Rhode Island, a family credited for generations with a natural gift for setting broken and dislocated bones. Job Sweet, “the first great ‘bonesetter,’” was styled Dr. Sweet, and during the Revolution was called to Newport to set dislocated bones for “the French officials.” (p. 61) The Sweet family
Marinda Sweet married Christopher “Stufel” Pickel, whose family lived on Hog Island in the early 1800s. Their granddaughter Christiana McCallum married Andrew Jackson Azeltine. (pp. 16, 59–60) The Pickel family
The McCallums came from Scotland. Duncan McCallum taught bookkeeping in a Vermont high school before the family moved to Montreal. (p. 63) The McCallum family
Sally Kennison, the wife of Ezra Bedley Aseltine, was believed by the compiler to descend from David Kennison, who is remembered as the last survivor of the Boston Tea Party. The book is frank that much of that connection is tradition. (pp. 65–69) The Kennison family
About 1943, and 1946
The book
Inez Fowler Johnson set out to trace her own line, and “many others were unearthed.” She dedicated the result to the memory of her mother, Nina Azeltine Fowler, whose memory was a chief source for it. (pp. 5, 9, 42)
She did not work alone. The foreword thanks E. A. Aseltine of Paw Paw, Michigan, and Harold Aseltine of Flint, “without whom these pages could not have been finished.” Laura Esseltine of Los Angeles made a wide search for the family’s records, and Kathryn Asseltine of Windsor, Ontario, supplied the families in Canada. (pp. 9, 51; addenda, p. 7)
Nor did she call it finished. “We do not wish to give the impression that this is complete,” she wrote. In 1946 she issued addenda that corrected the first generations and added the Thayer and Huffman families. This site follows the addenda wherever the two disagree. (p. 9)